Proletarians of all countries, unite!
There is one goal, the conquest of power!
REMARKS AT A BRIEFING
Chairman Mao Tse-tung
The Red Flag
REMARKS AT A BRIEFING
I have read your letter asking to have a talk with me. Recently I have been occupied with the struggle against revisionism and the like, so it has taken me some time to come and talk with you.
As you can see, we are struggling against Khrushchev. Can we win? We have struggled against enemies for a generation. We dared to struggle against imperialism, and defeated it. Who says we cannot defeat Khrushchev?!
We are now mainly in a struggle against imperialism and revisionism. As for reactionaries like Nehru they don‘t amount to too much!
1. ON THE HIGH TARGETS FOR GRAIN PRODUCTION PROPOSED BY SOME AT THE 1960 SHANGHAI MEETING
Truth, all truth, is ever in the hand of minority in the beginning. They will always have some compulsion exerted on them by the majority. 400 years ago Copernicus, a great Polish astronomer, discovered that the Earth moves. The theory that the heavens revolve about the Earth had ruled astronomy for over 1,000 years. The greatest achievement of Copernicus in his life time was to replace this theory with the scientific theory that the Earth revolves about the Sun. The religious circles of that time rallied together to attack him, to oppose him and accuse him of heresy. He was oppressed on all sides. His „De Revolutionibus“ was not published until he was on his deathbed (1543). He rejoiced in it. In Italy during that period the brilliant physicist and astronomer Galileo (1564-1642) subscribed to Copernicus‘ „heliocentric theory“. Beginning in 1609 he observed the heavens with a homemade telescope to see whether the stars moved, but he was persecuted by the religious circles of that time and convicted by the reactionary Roman court. Another person was burned to death. Burning an individual is nothing! Truth does not lie in their hands! Burn someone to death and the Earth still moves. A German invented sleeping potions. He was an apothecary in a pharmacy. The several people did their experiments in the shop. At first their aim was to alleviate the pain of women during childbirth. They carried out several experiments. Once eight people were poisoned and almost died, but finally they discovered a sleeping potion. But the Germans did not allow them to manufacture it or promote its sale. The French purchased their patent rights and invited the apothecary to France and held a meeting to welcome him. Only then was it disseminated. And most curiously, it did not thrive in one place, but did elsewhere. This kind of thing happens very frequently. For instance, buddhism was born in India, but it was not so tolerated in India; however, it thrived when it reached China and other places. As another example, at present marxism-leninism is not thriving in Europe or the Soviet Union, but it is in China. Darwin personally believed in religion. When his „Origin of Species“ was published, he was persecuted by religious circles which opposed him.
2. ON SOCIALIST EDUCATION
Recently we held a discussion to ratify two documents from the members of the Central Committee to the members of county committees. These documents are being read to the masses. It will take one or two years to finish this reading. I have recommended that whoever is not old and infirm (such as Hsu or Wu), whoever is not illiterate, and whoever has prestige among the masses (of course this does not mean Rightists; for instance, Peng Teh-huai1 must not go) should take part in this reading. The generals have all gone among the troops to read — they say it can be done! Why don‘t others do it?
In actuality, reading documents to the masses means to learn from the masses. If you want to go to a region to read, you first carry out investigation and study.
The „Four Clean-Ups“ and „Five Antis“ were taught to us by the masses. Nothing was engendered in our brains. The „Four Clean-Ups“ was proposed by the Paoting Special District Party Committee. Of the eight special district committees in Hopeh Province, only Paoting presented it. At the beginning even the Paoting Special District Party Committee did not understand how to carry out the „Four Clean-Ups“. Afterwards the masses submitted to them that it would not do to leave out the „Four Clean-Ups“, so they accepted it. Cadre participation in labour was taught to us by Hsiyang County, Shansi. Later there were also some materials on this from Chekiang Province.
3. ON THE CURRENT COUNTRYWIDE LAUNCHING OF A HIGH TIDE IN STUDYING THE WORKS OF CHAIRMAN MAO
The Selected Works of Mao, how much of it is mine! It is a work of blood. The struggle in the councils was very acute. Because of the errors of the Wang Ming line we had to embark on the 25,000 li Long March2. These things in Selected Works of Mao were taught to us by the masses and paid for with blood sacrifices.
Some articles should be rewritten, with new things included. The „Two On‘s“3 were written several decades ago. By now everything has developed and the contents have become richer. They should be revised.
4. ON THE LESSONS OF EXPERIENCE DURING THE THREE YEARS OF GREAT DEVELOPMENT, 1958-60
It was most beneficial. We could not have escaped the experience, for we would not have been able to learn how to engage in construction. We had no experience in countrywide construction. During the revolution we gained some experience in economic construction in the base areas. At that time the problems most urgently requiring solution were three: we needed food, we needed clothing, and we needed salt. Thus we had to develop production. These were the reasons for our engaging in economic construction at that time.4
I spent 10 years before and after the land reform program (documents of 1933). I could not have done it without the 10 years. During the great revolution I held two lecture and study sessions on the peasant movement, one in Kwangchow and one in Wuhan, and did some investigation and study, but still did not have a solution. Only later when I carried out eight investigations in Hsingkuo and other regions and investigated Changkang Township and Tsaichi Township, could I solve the problem. The masses taught it to me; they told me how to do it.
We spent 25 years studying revolution, from, 1921 to the 7th Party Congress in 19455. During the Yenan rectification6, we had come to know the Right-opportunism of Chen Tu-hsiu7 and the three „Left“-deviationist lines, especially that of Wang Ming8. We summed up these experiences. We were thereby able to develop into an army of 1,200,000, not counting the militia, by the close of the war of Resistance against Japan. The 7th Congress was excellent; it unified our thoughts and united the entire Party. Of course, there were still some problems, such as Kao Kang and Peng Teh-haui, but we still had faith in them. Peng Teh-huai later served as commander of the Northwest Field Army. In 1946 he had skirmishes with the Kuomintang, in July 1947 he began to counterattack — every month he exterminated eight brigades. What bravado! By 1948 he had successively taken Shichiachuang and Tsinan and later waged three great battles.
It took me 15 years to learn how to fight a war. In the beginning I did not know how to fight and did not even consider fighting. When the great revolution was defeated, we had 50,000 Party militants divided into several groups, one of which was killed, another capitulated, and still another did not venture to do anything and ran away. Only 1,000-2,000 people were left. According to statistics, there were still 800 at the time of the 7th Congress. In the several years since, some have died of age, so that only 600 are left, only 30 of them from Chingkangshan. At that time we had our backs to the wall and were compelled to pick up guns and learn to wage war. We had not entered any military academy. Only a minority had been to a military academy. The study of waging war was mainly taught to us by „teacher“ Chiang Kai-shek. He smashed the councils and caused us to undertake the 25,000 li Long March, 300,000 troops, of whom there remained only 20,000 when we reached North Shensi. And not all of these 20,000 people came on the Long March. They advanced through Yunyang and Tungcheng in Chingyang and Kuanchung in the Shensi-Kansu border areas. At that time I said that the 20,000 people were as strong as 300,000, not weaker. They traveled 25,000 li, their legs did the „talking“, made their speeches. In this way our brains had to think a bit. Only after the Tsunyi Conference9 did we change our ways and learn how to fight. Everything was forced upon us.
5. ON THE NECESSITY TO LEARN REVOLUTIONARY SPIRIT IN LEARNING FROM THE LIBERATION ARMY AND THE MINISTRY OF PETROLEUM AND TO FIGHT A WAR OF ANNIHILATION
We cannot be hasty. The socialist education campaign in the countryside must fight a war of annihilation. It is not enough time without these XXX or XXX years. At least four years: last year, this year, next year, the year after that are needed. We cannot be hasty. It will probably take XXX or XXX years or XXX or XXX years to completely master learning from the Liberation Army and the Ministry of Petroleum. We cannot be hasty with that either. Some provinces want to finish socialist education this year. That‘s too fast. It is a construction of XXX years or XXX years (indicates that a coal mine producing over XXX tens of thousands metric tons per year in the past required XXX years to construct). To speed this up or hurry it too much will not do. If you press it excessively it will be done in a phoney manner.
6. ON WHAT IT MEANS TO SUPPORT THE GENERAL LINE, THE GREAT LEAP FORWARD AND THE PEOPLE‘S COMMUNES
Class struggle, the struggle for production, and scientific experimentation must be linked up. Only carrying out the struggle for production and scientific experimentation but not grasping class struggle cannot kindle the spirit and enthusiasm of the people, nor can the struggle for production or scientific experimentation be done well. Will it do to only carry out the struggle for production and not scientific experimentation? To only carry out class struggle but not the struggle for the production or scientific experimentation, and to say „support the general line“, are meaningless. I say that the Ministry of Petroleum has made great achievements; it kindled the revolutionary spirit of the people and also built a XXX tens of thousands metric ton oil field. Moreover, it is not just a XXX tens of thousands ton oil field, but also a XXX ton refinery, of very high quality and up to international standards. This is the only way to convince people!
7. ON THE DECLINE IN REVOLUTIONARY WILL OF SOME COMRADES AND THE NECESSITY TO PROMOTE YOUNG CADRES
In the final analysis, are some people ill or is their revolutionary will declining? Or did they go dancing six times a week? Or is it love of beauty but not country? Some say they are so sick that they cannot do their work. Can an illness be that bad?!… Like certain comrades, in the final analysis, do they love beauty or country? In my view, when we ask them to do XXX, they may not necessarily be able to do it well. We should give them a „prime minister“.
For many years we have advocated going out to do investigation and study. But they did not go out. They have been engaging in industry for so many years yet they do not know what industry is. They do not understand machinery or equipment: what can they do!
At present we must promote young cadres. At the time of the Chihpi War and the Chunyinghui, Chuko Liang was 27 years old, as was Sun Chuan. Sun Tse was doing things when he was only 17 or 18 years old. When Chou Yu died he was not over 36 years old; at that time he was about 30. Tsao Tsao was 53. In fact, young people beat the old. „In the Yangtse River the rear waves push those in front; in the world new people chase after the old.“
8. ON CHEN YUNG-KUEI OF TACHAI PRODUCTION TEAM
But we should not look down on the under-educated. During the National People‘s Congress, XXX, a comrade of mine who is now a lieutenant governor of Hupeh Province, asked to speak with me. He said that he has now come to understand that intellectuals have the least knowledge. Throughout history, many emperors were intellectuals but were unsuccessful: Sui Yang-ti could write essays and poetry; Chen Hou-chu and Li Hou-chu could write poetry and were good at narrative verse; Sung Ha-tsung could write poetry and paint. Some of the under-educated can do great things: Genghis Khan was an illiterate. Liu Pang too could not read a dozen characters, and was undereducated. Chu Yuan-chang was also illiterate, a cattle herder. In our military ranks there are many undereducated, but only a few intellectuals. Hsu Shih-yu10 studied for a few days! XXX has never had any formal education, nor have Han Hsien-chu or Chen Hsi-lien. XXX went to senior primary school, as did Liu Ya-lou11. Of course, we cannot do without several intellectuals. We consider Lin Piao, Hsu Hsiang-chien, XXX, XXX… to be middle grade intellectuals. My conclusion is that the under-educated can defeat the students of Whampoa.
9. ON HOW CURRENT PRACTICES ARE ALRIGHT, WHEREIN EVERYONE WANTS TO ENGAGE IN CRITICISM AND SELF-CRITICISM AND TO LEARN FROM OTHERS
Everything is one divided into two. I personally am also one divided into two. I was a primary school teacher, and when I was young, I also believed in the spirits. I went with my mother to distant temples to burn incense. Before the October Revolution, I did not even know there was a Marx, or anything which occurred after Marx.
Is there anyone who has not committed a mistake? Some of our comrades enjoy metaphysics. What is metaphysics? It is one-sidedness, allowing only the good to be said and not the bad and being fond of only hearing good and not the bad. Like XXX, a good comrade, but he does not want to let people see their bad points, only their good; they are mortally afraid they will touch a sore point.
Marx was also one divided into two. Marx‘s philosophy was learned from Hegel and Feuerbach, his economics from England‘s Ricardo and others, and from France he studied utopian socialism. All this was bourgeois. From this, one divided into two and produced marxism. Let me ask you, when Marx was young did he ever read Marx‘s works?
This Party of ours is also one divided into two.
Before opposing an encirclement and suppression, some people said that one could not run an army without beating people; how could one lead the troops without beatings? At that time warlordism was really vicious! The soldiers said: „Cherish the soldiers, cherish the soldiers, the company commander rides the horse.“ This phase was incorrect, the company commander should ride the horse.
Peng has always carried out splittism. During the time of the Central Council-controlled areas, Li Li-san‘s line emerged. They were so „Left“! They wanted to strike against the large cities, against Chiuchiang, Wuhan, and Changsha. I said it would not work; they said we had to strike. At that time there was a Chian Area Party Committee secretary, Li Wen-lin, who wrote a letter to the Central Committee stating emphatically that it was the consciousness of the peasants to divide the land and develop and consolidate the land reform and that to first attack Chian then Chiuchiang would definitely throw away the revolution. That is to say that we had to attack Chiuchiang was quite „Left“! We have had 10 years of civil war. The intraparty struggle is very serious.
The 5th Plenum elected Chang Weng-tien12 to the Political Bureau when he was not even a member of the Central Committee. If we now investigate whether or not Chang was a Party member, when he entered the Party, or who introduced him, we will not be able to find the answer. Nonetheless he was elected to the Political Bureau, while I, a member of the Political Bureau, was not allowed to participate in the Congress.
By the Tsunyi Conference on the Long March, the situation had some changes. There should be a differentiation made in the Wang Ming line. It was different before and after the Tsunyi conference.
In parleying with the 4th Front Army, we spoke honestly and told Chang Kuo-tao13 that we began with 80,000 troops, but then only had 30,000 left. We did speak honestly! At that time the 4th Front Army still had 80,000 troops. Chang Kuo-tao demanded the power of directorship from us, but we did not give it. Chang Kuo-tao‘s errors were errors of line.
Afterwards we arrived in North Shensi. The War of Resistance was also not without problems. There was the Wang Ming line and things like Peng Teh-huai‘s Hundred Regiments Battle. Before the 7th Party Congress, we held a conference to struggle against Peng Teh-huai. Did he not say at the Lushan Conference14: „You curse me for 40 days, so I curse you for 20 days“? You participated at the Yenan struggle session! He did not disperse (indicating the Hundred Regiments Battle); he insisted on concentrating his forces. In actuality, at that time a platoon could have developed into a regiment or a division.
Was it still one divides into two after liberation? The Kao-Jao anti-Party clique in 1953 was a great revelation. At the finance conference they said XXX and XXX were sectarians. I said that the Chinese revolution has scaled many peaks. Without peaks, where is the revolution? At that time we also did not have a common program.
Peng and Kao Kang united together in North Shensi. I had not thought that Teng Hua would also work with them. Teng Hua told me that he felt that Chingkangshan had no peak and was very unattractive. Afterward he sought out Peng. The late Chen Kuang also felt there were no peaks and was dissatisfied.
In 1962 they were again unable to speak of classes and class struggle how unsteady would each department be! Teng Tzu-hui15 wanted to „contract to the households“. In the past Wang Chia-hsiang16 had always been ill. For that half a year he was healthy and wanted to have „Three Reconciliations and One Reduction“, with such activism! What we must now do is „Three Struggles and One Increase“. The United Front Department wants the political parties of the bourgeoisie to become socialist political parties and drew up a five-year plan. They softly, softly fell; it was a surrender to the bourgeoisie. At that time they wanted to carry out „Three Reconciliations and One Reduction“ internationally and „Three Freedoms and One Guarantee“ domestically. Peng Teh-huai‘s letter of attack also came out at that time as did Hsi Chung-hsun‘s book17 „Liu Chih-tan“.
10. ON READING
There is some truth in the foolish old man who moved the mountains. Within one or several million years a mountain may flatten. The foolish old man put it correctly: after his death would come his sons, and after them more sons. The grandsons would have sons, and sons and grandsons will continue to be produced. But the mountain will not increase in height. There must eventually come a day when it is levelled.
To talk about philosophy for half an hour is enough: if you talk longer you would not talk clearly. We also do not want to read too many books. Reading several dozens will do. The more you read, the more unclear things become.
11. ON GRAIN LEVIES, PURCHASES AND TRANSFERS IN THE COUNTRYSIDE
Some districts do not have basic food rations. I do not approve. They should have basic food rations.
1Peng Teh-hui — Up to 1959 the minister of defence. In July 1959, at the Lushan Conference, a group of Party directors headed by him criticized the Great Leap Forward and its directorship as „small-bourgeois fanaticism“. They argued that it had created far more damage than good. After a major struggle at the plenum conference, Peng and other Rightists were removed from their positions of responsibility in the Party and the government.
2The Long March of 25,000 li (12,500 kilometres) was made by Red Army from Kiangsi Province to Northern Shensi Province. In October 1934 the 1st, 3rd and 5th Army Groups of the Chinese Workers and Peasants‘ Red Army (that is, the 1st Front Army of the Red Army, also known as the Central Red Army) set out from Changting and Ninghua in Western Fukien and from Juichin, Yutu and other places in Southern Kiangsi and started a major strategic movement. In traversing the 11 provinces of Fukien, Kiangsi, Kwangtung, Hunan Kwangsi, Kweichow, Szechwan, Yunnan, Sikang, Kansu and Shensi, crossing perpetually snow-capped mountains and trackless grasslands, sustaining untold hardships and frustrating the enemy‘s repeated encirclements, pursuits, obstructions and interceptions, the Red Army covered 25,000 li (12,500 kilometers) on this march and finally arrived triumphantly at the revolutionary base area in Northern Shensi in October 1935.
3See Chairman Mao Tse-tung: „On Practice“, July 1937, and „On Contradiction“, August 1937.
4In this connection see Chairman Mao Tse-tung‘s report entitled „Economic and Financial Problems in the Anti-Japanese War“, 1942.
5The 7th National Congress of the Communist Party of China was held in Yenan between April 23rd and June 11th, 1945. The Congress laid down the Party line: go all out, mobilize the masses, expand the people‘s forces and under the directorship of our Party, defeat the Japanese aggressors, liberate the Chinese people and build a new democratic China. It adopted a Party Constitution designating Mao Tse-tung thought, which integrates the marxist-leninist theories with the practice of the Chinese revolution, as the guideline for all Party work. This Congress witnessed unprecedented Party unity ideologically, politically and organizationally.
6This refers to the movement for rectifying the style of work conducted by the Communist Party of China in 1942-43 throughout the Party. Its content was the combating of subjectivism, sectarianism and stereotyped writing. Under the leadership of Chairman Mao Tse-tung, this rectification movement adopted the principles of „learning from past mistakes to avoid future ones“, „curing the sickness to save the patient“ and „clearing up wrong thinking while uniting with comrades“. Through the method of criticism and self-criticism, the movement corrected the „Left“ and Right errors which had occurred on various occasions in the history of the Party by getting down to their ideological roots, greatly raised the ideological level of the broad ranks of Party cadres, helped immensely to unify thinking within the Party on the basis of marxism-leninism and thus brought about a high degree of unity in the whole Party. See Chairman Mao Tse-tung: „Reform Our Study“, May 1941, „Rectify the Party‘s Style of Work“, 01.02.1942, and „Oppose Stereotyped Party Writing“, 08.02.1942.
7Chen Tu-hsiu was originally a professor at Peking University and became famous as an editor of New Youth. He was one of the founders of Communist Party of China. Owing to his reputation at the time of the May 4th Movement and owing to the Party‘s immaturity in its initial period, he became General Secretary of the Party. In the last period of the revolution of 1924-27, the Rightist thinking in the Party represented by Chen Tu-hsiu developed into a line of capitulationism. In „The Present Situation and Our Tasks“, 25.12.1947, Chairman Mao Tse-tung said that the capitulationists at that time „voluntarily gave up the Party‘s directorship of the peasant masses, urban small bourgeoisie and middle bourgeoisie, and in particular gave up the Party‘s directorship of the armed force, thus causing the defeat of the revolution“. After the defeat in 1927 Chen Tu-hsiu and a handful of other capitulationists lost faith in the future of the revolution and became liquidationists. They took the reactionary trotskyist position and together with the trotskyites formed a small anti-Party group. Consequently Chen Tu-hsiu was expelled from the Party in November 1929. He died in 1942. With references to Chen Tu-hsiu‘s Right-opportunism, see the introductory notes to „Analysis of the Classes in Chinese Society“, March 1926, and to „Report on an Investigation of the Peasant Movement in Hunan“, March 1927, and „Introducing The Communist“, October 1939.
8A reference to Li Li-san‘s and Wang Ming‘s lines. The „Left“-opportunism of Li Li-san, generally known as the „Li Li-san line“, refers to the „Left“-opportunist line which existed in the Party for about four months beginning from June 1930 and which was represented by Comrade Li Li-san, then the most influential leader of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China. The Li Li-san line had the following characteristics: It violated the policy of the Party‘s 6th National Congress; it denied that masses strength had to be built up for the revolution and denied that the development of the revolution was uneven; it regarded as „extremely erroneous […] localism and conservatism characteristics of peasant mentality“ the ideas of Chairman Mao Tse-tung that for a long time we should devote our attention mainly to creating rural base areas, use the rural areas to encircle the cities and use these bases to advance a high tide of countrywide revolution, and it held that preparations should be made for immediate insurrections in all parts of the country. On the basis of this erroneous line, Comrade Li Li-san drew up an adventurist plan for organising immediate armed insurrections in the key cities throughout the country. At the same time, he refused to recognize the uneven development of the world revolution, holding that the general outbreak of the Chinese revolution would inevitably lead to general outbreak of world revolution, without which the Chinese revolution could not be successful; he also refused to recognize the protracted nature of China‘s bourgeois-democratic revolution, holding that the beginnings of victory in one or more provinces would mark the beginning of the transition to socialist revolution, and thus formulated a number of inappropriate „Left“-adventurist policies. Chairman Mao Tse-tung opposed this erroneous line, and the broad masses of cadres and militants in the Party also demanded its rectification. At the 3rd Plenum of the Party‘s 6th Central Committee in September 1930 Comrade Li Li-san admitted the mistakes that had been pointed out and then relinquished his directing position in the Central Committee. Over a long period of time Comrade Li Li-san corrected his wrong views, and so he was reelected to the Central Committee at the 7th National Congress of the Party.
The 3rd of the 6th Central Committee of the Party held in September 1930, and the subsequent central directing body adopted many positive measures to put an end to the Li Li-san line. But later a number of Party comrades who were inexperienced in practical revolutionary struggle, with Chen Shao-yu (Wang Ming) and Chin Pang-hsien (Po Ku) in the lead, came out against in the Central Committee‘s measures. In the pamphlet, „The Two Lines, or the Struggle for the Further Bolshevization of the Communist Party of China“, they most emphatically declared that the main danger then existing in the Party was not „Left“-opportunism but „Right-opportunism“ and to justify their own activities they „criticized“ the Li Li-san line as „Rightist“. They put forward a new political programme which continued, revived or developed the Li Li-san line and other „Left“ ideas and policies in a new guise, and set themselves against the correct line of Chairman Mao Tse-tung. It was mainly to criticize the military mistakes of this new „Left“-opportunist line that Chairman Mao Tse-tung wrote the article „Problems of Strategy in China‘s Revolutionary War“ (December 1936). This line was dominant in the Party from the 4th Plenum of the 6th Central Committee in January 1931 to the meeting of the Political Bureau convened by the Central Committee at Tsunyi, Kweichow Province, in January 1935, which ended the dominance of this erroneous line and established the new central directorship headed by Chairman Mao Tse-tung. The erroneous „Left“ line dominated the Party for a particularly long time (four years) and brought extremely heavy losses, with disastrous consequences, to the Party and the revolution. A loss of 90% was inflicted on the Communist Party of China, the Chinese Red Army and its base areas, tens of million of people in the revolutionary base areas were made to suffer the cruel oppression of the Kuomintang, and the progress of the Chinese revolution was retarded.
9The Tsunyi Meeting was the enlarged meeting of the Political Bureau called by the Central Committee of the Communist Party of China at Tsunyi, Kweichow Province, in January 1935.
10Hsu Shih-yu (c. 1906) was at this time Commander of the Nanking Military Region, and Vice-Minister of National Defence. (He had been appointed to this latter post in 1959, when Lin Piao took over the Ministry from Peng Teh-huai.) At the 9th Congress in April 1969, he had become a member of the Political Bureau.
11Liu Ya-lou, a commander of the People‘s Liberation Army Air Force.
12Chang Wen-tien (c.1898), pseudonym Lo Fu, a member of the „28½ Bolsheviks“, succeeded Chin Pang-hsien (Po Ku) as General Secretary at the Tsunyi Conference of January 1935. He was Chinese Ambassador to Moscow from 1951 to 1955, and thereafter a Vice-Minister of Foreign Affairs until 1959. He was a member of the Peng anti-Party clique. For some more details see Chairman Mao‘s „Letter to Chang Wan-tien“ and „Comment on Chang Wan-tien‘s Letter“.
13Chang Kuo-tao was a renegade from the Chinese revolution. In early life, speculating on the revolution, he joined the Communist Party of China. In the Party he made many mistakes resulting in serious crimes. The most notorious of these was his opposition in 1935, to the Red Army‘s northward march and his defeatism and liquidationism in advocating withdrawal by the Red Army to the minority nationality areas on the Szechwan-Sikang borders; what is more, he openly carried out traitorous activities against the Party and Central Committee, established his own bogus „Central Committee“, disrupted the unity of the Party and the Red Army, and caused heavy losses to the 4th Front Army of the Red Army. But thanks to patient education by Chairman Mao Tse-tung and the Central Committee, the 4th Front Army and its numerous cadres soon returned to the correct directorship of the Central Committee of the Party and played a glorious role in subsequent struggles. Chang Kuo-tao, however, proved incorrigible and in the Spring of 1938 he slipped out of the Shensi-Kansu-Ningsia Border Region and joined the Kuomintang secret police.
14The Lushan Conference was held during July 1959.
15Teng Tzu-hui (1895-1972) had been head of the Rural Work Department since 1952.
16Wang Chia-hsiang (1907-74) was, a member of the „28½ Bolsheviks“ faction. He was China‘s first ambassador to the Soviet Union in 1949-51, and participated in the Chinese delegation to the Moscow meeting of November 1957, led by Mao Tse-tung, but he faded from the scene in early 1960s. He was, however, reelected to the Central Committee at the 10th Congress in 1973.
17Hsi Chang-hsun, a member of the Peng anti-Party clique.